Welcome to my Flight Review For 2015!
I like to wish all readers a great year ahead!
Introduction
This year passed very quickly and I am quite pleased with my number of flights I took this year. It may be lesser than last year but still, I got to meet new people and gained new experience along the way. My flights may not be as many or glamorous as some of the other travellers, but I am satisfied. One can never be too greedy.
As usual, my reviews are based on my flying experience with these airlines and I don't work for any of them. This review will be similar to my previous year review, just a slight update to enhance it.
I will give a short review of each airline I flew on, including the aircraft types and a grade for each one of them. After the review section, I will announce the results of Charles Ryan's Flying Award to the airlines flown under the following categories such as 'Best In-flight Experience', 'Best livery' and ...etc.
*Aircraft photos are credited to the respective photographers from Airliners.net
Without further ado, let's begin!
This is the map of my flights in 2015
Only Asian countries this year, I have to change that for the year 2016. Currently, have plans to go to Europe and Australia depending on how things work out.
Flights: 46
Miles: 33525
Type of classes: First Class - Nil, Business Class - 6, Premium Economy - 2, Economy Class - 38
Most flown aircraft type: Boeing 737-800 (8 times)
New aircraft types for 2015: Boeing 737-900 (Non-ER), Boeing 787-9, MD-83
Number of airlines flown: 23
Number of airlines flown: 23
Airlines flew in 2015
-Scoot (2 times B787-9 and 1 time B787-8)
Asiana (1 time A380 and 1 time B747-400 Combi)
Korean Air (1 time B777-200ER and 2 times B737-900)
Jeju Air (1 time B737-800)
Jin Air (1 time B737-800 and 1 time B777-200ER)
Oman Air (1 time Airbus A330-200 and 1 time Airbus A330-300)
KLM (1 time Boeing 777-200ER)
Batik Air (2 times Boeing 737-800)
Air France (1 time Boeing 777-200ER)
Malaysia Airlines (2 times Boeing 737-800)
TigerAir (1 time Airbus A320)
TigerAir Taiwan ( 1 time Airbus A320)
Air Asia (1 time Airbus A320)
EVA Air (2 times Boeing 777-300ER)
Xiamen Air (2 times Boeing 737-800, 2 times Boeing 787-8)
Hong Kong Airlines (2 times Airbus A330-200, 2 times Airbus A330-300)
V Air (2 times Airbus A321)
Far Eastern Air Transport (2 times MD-82, 2 times MD-83)
China Airlines (1 time Airbus A330-300, 1 time Boeing 737-800)
Uni Air (1 time ATR-72-600)
Mandarin Airlines (1 time ERJ-190)
TransAsia (2 times ATR-72-600)
Thai Lion Air (1 time Boeing 737-800)
Airports visited in 2015
Hong Kong (HKG)
Seoul Incheon (ICN)
Seoul Gimpo (GMP)
Jeju (CJU)
Busan (PUS)
Kuala Lumpur (KUL)
Jakarta (CGK)
Yogyakarta (YOG)
Taipei Taoyuan (TPE)
Taipei Songshan (TSA)
Xiamen (XMN)
Beijing (PEK)
Chiang Mai (CNX)
Kinmen (KNH)
Kaohsiung (KHH)
Magong (MZG)
Hualien (HUN)
Bangkok (DMK)
New airports for 2015: Yogyakata, Busan, Kaohsiung and Hualien
Airline's review (Summary)
One Class - Economy
Boeing 777-300ER F-GSQG (CGK-SIN) (Link to the trip report)
Airbus A380-800 HL7625 (ICN-HKG) (Link to the trip report)
My thoughts: Very lucky to have a pretty empty upper deck Economy Class cabin and that made my experience even more enjoyable. Cabin service wasn't as good as the 747 Combi, but overall it was a great experience flying on the 'Whalejet' once again. In-flight entertainment system and meal were decent.
Overall rating: A - Apart from the website, the airline's service indeed deserves the 5-star rating from Skytrax and other numerous airline rating websites. I find the IFE system on the Boeing 747-400 Combi to be quite decent and Airbus A380's is obviously better - certainly good enough to keep you entertained for long haul flights. The meals on both flights are not the best though.
Boeing 737-900ER PK-LBM (CGK-YOG-CGK) (Link to part 1 and Link to part 2)
Economy Class
My thoughts: Identical cabin as Malindo and I find this to be one of the best. Decent legroom space - 32' inch, with comfortable legroom space and good IFE system even though it has limited contents inside. For the price, It is a bargain if you ask me. In-flight service was a great and complimentary snack and drink was given. A decent boutique airline set up by the Lion Airlines Group.
Business Class
My thoughts: A true business class product, unlike some airlines that use Economy Class seats and block out the middle. The price I paid for this is certainly a bargain especially and this encourages more passengers to pay a bit more to enjoy without splashing a lot with the 'big boys'. In-flight meal was provided on this short 1-hour flight and it was not bad! The headset was provided and the IFE system is the foldable type only used during in-flight. Excellent service even though the crew could hardly speak any English.
Overall rating: A - One of the top airlines in Indonesia and in my first choice when flying on domestic flights. Both Economy Class and Business Class products can be said to be better than some of the premium carrier's products out there.
Airbus A330-300 B-18351 (TPE-HKG) Link to the trip report
Economy Class
My thoughts: Old cabin interior which needs to be updated. Seat pitch is reasonable in a comfortable 2-4-2 layout. Disappointed not to fly on the Triple 7, but at least I got this off my flight logbook. In-flight service was definitely better than my first experience with this airline and the snack bar was pretty good for this short hop. IFE system is not-AVOD (Audio Video on Demand) but it contains the latest movies, so not too bad for short hops.
Boeing 737-800 B-18309 (HKG-TPE) Link to this trip report
Economy Class
My thoughts: I find the seats to be slightly more comfortable than the A330 and B747-400. The Boeing 737-800s are equipped with drop-down screens and for my flight, I flew on a 17-years old 737-800, was quite disappointed but at least the aircraft was in good condition and interior was clean. In-flight service was good and the snack box for the return leg was as good if not better than the first leg (A330 flight).
Overall rating: B- Cabin interior of both aircraft is dated but for the Boeing 737-800, it should be bearable for the short regional routes, as for the Airbus A330-300 and Boeing 747-400, its pointless refurbishing the interior since they are scheduled to be retired. (747-400 first)
Boeing 777-300ER B-16722 (Hello Kitty # 7) (SIN-TPE-SIN)
Link to part 1 and Link to part 2
Economy Class
My thoughts: This is definitely an upgrade over the older Economy Class cabin. Newer (In-flight Entertainment system) IFE and seats which give the passengers some comfort for the long haul. Although the seat pitch is reduced (33' inch to 32' inch), it is still comfortable especially the airline retains the 3-3-3 seating configuration. I like the seat colour, in particular, find it to be quite attractive. As this is a Hello Kitty flight, you can seat cover, seat pocket items are all based on this Japanese character. In-flight meal was not bad and the cabin service was good. I find this experience better than most of my previous flights with this airline.
Elite Class (Premium Economy)
Airline's review (Summary)
Airbus A320 9M-AHF (SIN-KUL) (No Trip Report)
One Class - Economy
My thoughts: 2nd time flying on 9M-AHF - I was naturally disappointed since Air Asia operates many A320s, well that's life! Cabin seats are the standard - tight legroom space. Service was mediocre but at least I got to my destination pretty much on time. Didn't order a meal since this was a short flight and I wasn't hungry.
Overall rating: C- That's the best I can give. The staff couldn't be bothered and were grumpy, that minus a lot of points for me.
Premium Economy
My thoughts: I was originally booked on Economy Class and only decided to upgrade my class to Premium Economy when I received an email offer of $72 for the short flight. At first, I was hesitant but because I dread the feeling of flying in the 3-4-3 configuration in Y class, I thought I might as well do it since I don't know when would be my next time flying with this airline. While I enjoyed the Premium Economy product, the in-flight service, on the other hand, was a big disappointment. The crew were arrogant and a few of them were lacking professionalism I feel. The in-flight snack box was the same as Economy Class.
Overall rating: B- The in-flight service was a disappointment and is the main reason for the rating.
Boeing 747-400 Combi HL7421 (HKG-ICN) (Link to the trip report)
Economy Class
My thoughts: Very happy to have flown on this airline's Boeing 747 Combi. As you know, this airline along with a few others are well known for making last-minute equipment changes, so when I saw this aircraft coming from Incheon, I was delighted. In-flight service was excellent. In-flight meal and IFE system were pretty decent too.
Upper deck Economy Class
My thoughts: Very lucky to have a pretty empty upper deck Economy Class cabin and that made my experience even more enjoyable. Cabin service wasn't as good as the 747 Combi, but overall it was a great experience flying on the 'Whalejet' once again. In-flight entertainment system and meal were decent.
Overall rating: A - Apart from the website, the airline's service indeed deserves the 5-star rating from Skytrax and other numerous airline rating websites. I find the IFE system on the Boeing 747-400 Combi to be quite decent and Airbus A380's is obviously better - certainly good enough to keep you entertained for long haul flights. The meals on both flights are not the best though.
Economy Class
My thoughts: Identical cabin as Malindo and I find this to be one of the best. Decent legroom space - 32' inch, with comfortable legroom space and good IFE system even though it has limited contents inside. For the price, It is a bargain if you ask me. In-flight service was a great and complimentary snack and drink was given. A decent boutique airline set up by the Lion Airlines Group.
Business Class
My thoughts: A true business class product, unlike some airlines that use Economy Class seats and block out the middle. The price I paid for this is certainly a bargain especially and this encourages more passengers to pay a bit more to enjoy without splashing a lot with the 'big boys'. In-flight meal was provided on this short 1-hour flight and it was not bad! The headset was provided and the IFE system is the foldable type only used during in-flight. Excellent service even though the crew could hardly speak any English.
Overall rating: A - One of the top airlines in Indonesia and in my first choice when flying on domestic flights. Both Economy Class and Business Class products can be said to be better than some of the premium carrier's products out there.
Airbus A330-300 B-18351 (TPE-HKG) Link to the trip report
Economy Class
My thoughts: Old cabin interior which needs to be updated. Seat pitch is reasonable in a comfortable 2-4-2 layout. Disappointed not to fly on the Triple 7, but at least I got this off my flight logbook. In-flight service was definitely better than my first experience with this airline and the snack bar was pretty good for this short hop. IFE system is not-AVOD (Audio Video on Demand) but it contains the latest movies, so not too bad for short hops.
Boeing 737-800 B-18309 (HKG-TPE) Link to this trip report
Economy Class
My thoughts: I find the seats to be slightly more comfortable than the A330 and B747-400. The Boeing 737-800s are equipped with drop-down screens and for my flight, I flew on a 17-years old 737-800, was quite disappointed but at least the aircraft was in good condition and interior was clean. In-flight service was good and the snack box for the return leg was as good if not better than the first leg (A330 flight).
Overall rating: B- Cabin interior of both aircraft is dated but for the Boeing 737-800, it should be bearable for the short regional routes, as for the Airbus A330-300 and Boeing 747-400, its pointless refurbishing the interior since they are scheduled to be retired. (747-400 first)
Boeing 777-300ER B-16722 (Hello Kitty # 7) (SIN-TPE-SIN)
Link to part 1 and Link to part 2
Economy Class
My thoughts: This is definitely an upgrade over the older Economy Class cabin. Newer (In-flight Entertainment system) IFE and seats which give the passengers some comfort for the long haul. Although the seat pitch is reduced (33' inch to 32' inch), it is still comfortable especially the airline retains the 3-3-3 seating configuration. I like the seat colour, in particular, find it to be quite attractive. As this is a Hello Kitty flight, you can seat cover, seat pocket items are all based on this Japanese character. In-flight meal was not bad and the cabin service was good. I find this experience better than most of my previous flights with this airline.
Elite Class (Premium Economy)
My thoughts: This is the 2-4-2 seating configuration, an upgrade over the old Elite Class product on the 77N. I got to try both products and I say this has to be better. Although the seats look simple and don't give you that luxurious feeling like some other airline's Premium Economy, it is comfortable and more importantly has the legroom space. The service and in-flight meal on this flight were average, not as good as my previous flight.
Overall rating: A- Cabin service is still not quite there as you can see the faces of some of the crew looking stress, instead of enjoying their jobs. On the other hand, the in-flight products on this 77A configured Boeing 777-300ER impress me, won't have any problem flying long haul on this product especially the Economy Class.
FAT MD-82 B-28021, B-28027 (TSA - KNH - KHH) (Link to my part 1 and link to my part 2) and MD-83 B-28011 (TSA-KNH-TSA) - No Trip Report
B-28021
One Class- Economy Class
My thoughts: McDonnell Douglas MD-80/90 and Boeing 717 seating configuration are in a 2-3 Economy Class layout, comfortable for the passengers but not so good for the accountants in the companies, that's why most operators have already replaced this aircraft type with either Airbus A320 or Boeing 737. Sitting at the 2-seater is better as there is more legroom space. Cabin service was average but at least a snack was served along with the drink.
B-28017
Economy Class
My thoughts: Similar experience comparing to my previous flight, but at least I got some privacy at my seat 30A. Taking photos of the interior was not a problem but no electronic devices can be used during taking off and landing as someone told me that they prefer to keep the old rule as the aircraft type was old.
Overall rating: B+ Not many folks appreciate this aircraft especially sitting at the rear. For me, I give most of the points to my experience onboard. The good thing was the enjoyable ride on all 4 sectors and snack was offered on the flights, but the cabin service is the weakest among my Taiwanese flights so far.
Hong Kong Airlines Airbus A330-300 B-LNP (Photo below) and B-LNM
The newer Business Class cabin
My thoughts: I don't like this staggered style business class cabin, to be honest, finding it to be quite cramped. I chose the aisle access and its pretty much lack of privacy, so choose the windows seats if you have an option. Unfortunately, one of my flights' IFE system was down but one of the crew was apologetic about it and kept coming around my side to check whether I was ok, that's good service. Overall, the in-flight meals were average but the cabin service was good on both flights.
Hong Kong Airlines Airbus A330-200 B-LNI (Photo below) and B-LNE
Old Business Class Cabin
My thoughts: One of my flights supposed to be operated by an Airbus A330-200 equipped with the new cabin, but it was changed to this old cabin which is configured with more seats. I prefer this cabin configuration as there are more space and privacy. This product may be dated, but it works for me for my short flights. Cabin service on both flights was good and in-flight meal decent.
My overall rating: B+ Nothing spectacular about both old and new Business Class products, but still lose out to the top airlines. However, for the price I paid, I have no complaint! Cabin service on all 4 flights was good, and in-flight meals, to be honest, were underwhelming for Business Class standard, but overall I had a enjoy my flights with this airline.
Jeju Air Boeing 737-800 HL8261 (GMP-CJU) (link to the trip report)
My thoughts: Another excellent flight experience with this airline. Even though it was just a short 50 minutes flight, the cabin crew were friendly and professional throughout and the Captain gave regular updates on our flight progress. A complimentary drink was served and now electronic devices in in-flight mode are allowed to be used on Korean airlines. For the fare I paid, it is definitely value for money.
Overall rating: This airline is reliable, has a good safety record and is expanding well. I flew this airline on both domestic and international routes and I am impressed with both on the ground and in-flight service, definitely in my recommendation list.
One Class: Economy
Thoughts: Korean Air transferred some Boeing 737-800s to this airline and the cabin interior is retained, the only thing different is the seat headcover. Seat pitch is pretty tight, especially at the last row. In-flight service was great and a complimentary drink was served. I still don't get why the airline doesn't offer domestic flights for the English version of the website. If you want to book on the airline's domestic flight, you can try booking via a travel agency in Korea or purchase the ticket at the ticketing office at Gimpo Airport.
Jin Air's Boeing 777-200ER HL7443 (CJU-GMP) Link to the trip report
Thoughts: Jin Air has an interesting layout of both 2-5-2 and 3-4-3 Economy Class cabin (First 2 sections: 2-5-2 and last section: 3-4-3). This is the only airline with such configuration on a Boeing 777. The seats are from Korean Air's and I sat at the 3-seater (3-4-3). I chose the 3-4-3 to see for myself how cramp it was. Legroom space is not too bad but if you are flying alone, go for the 2-seater of the 2-5-2 configuration. As for the service, I have to give credit to the crew for handling this flight well. Not a frown on their faces at all even when they encounter some challenges from the passengers. Drink service was served and they basically completed it fast and within the time frame of the short 50 minutes flight. Well done to this set of the crew!
Overall rating: A+ Excellent service especially on the Boeing 777 flight. The aircraft may be transferred from Korean Air with its interior but comparing to other Low-Cost Carriers, the seat comfort is better. The airline also has a map of the aircraft type and will notify you of the windowless seats on the aircraft you are flying on. The on the ground and in-flight crew were excellent for both flights and this airline is definitely in my list of recommendation.
KLM's Boeing 777-200ER PH-BQD (KUL-CGK) (Link to the trip report)
My thoughts: 3-3-3 old Y class on this aircraft may be slightly more comfortable (less 1 seat a row) than the newly configured 3-4-3 Y class products introduced by KLM some time ago. However, I find this to be quite outdated and a bit cramped due to the seat pitch. I didn't quite enjoy this flight because my leg was aching towards the end of the 2 hours trip but at least the cabin crew were friendly. The snack bag was disappointing, I was hoping for a full meal for this 2 hours flight, I guess that's part of the reason for the cheap airfare.
Overall rating: B- Outdated In-flight product, average looking cabin and a light snack are not my taste. On the other hand, the in-flight service was good and that is probably one of the few highlights of this flight.
My thoughts: The flight to Busan was pretty bumpy and I feel that the Captain should have made the cabin crew stripped up especially when the aircraft was going through the rough turbulence. Fortunately, the crew managed to be seated. As for me, I had the whole row to myself so no complaints about the seat pitch, and besides the seat itself is comfortable. In-flight service was excellent and like the Korean Low-Cost Carriers, only a drink was served, but you could ask for refills.
Korean Air's Boeing 777-200ER, HL-7750 (GMP-CJU) (Link to the trip report)
My thoughts: It was a great experience onboard this Korean Air's Boeing 777. Fitted with 3-3-3 seating configuration, it was equipped with not the most modern IFE system but it is comfortable with ample legroom space, I like it. In-flight service was excellent and I felt the crew dealt well with a full load of passengers on this short flight. The only drink was served.
Overall rating: A+ 3 great flights with Korean Air. The crew, in particular, were helpful and accommodating to my photography session especially after the flight. Not the most modern cabin around but at least for me, I can cope with it if I fly the 777 on long haul routes.
Malaysia Airlines' Boeing 737-800 9M-MSF (Photo) and 9M-MXE (SIN-KUL-SIN)
(Link to part 1 and Link to part 2)
My thoughts: I was delighted to have finally gotten the airline's newer Boeing 737-800s. Both flights were less than 30% full and most of us had the whole row to ourselves. How is the airline making money? Only the airline knows. For me, it was definitely a bargain as I enjoyed both the ride and the wonderful Malaysian hospitality.
One Class: Economy
My thoughts: Another excellent flight experience with this airline. Even though it was just a short 50 minutes flight, the cabin crew were friendly and professional throughout and the Captain gave regular updates on our flight progress. A complimentary drink was served and now electronic devices in in-flight mode are allowed to be used on Korean airlines. For the fare I paid, it is definitely value for money.
Overall rating: This airline is reliable, has a good safety record and is expanding well. I flew this airline on both domestic and international routes and I am impressed with both on the ground and in-flight service, definitely in my recommendation list.
Jin Air Boeing 737-800 HL7557 (GMP-CJU) (Link to the trip report)
Thoughts: Korean Air transferred some Boeing 737-800s to this airline and the cabin interior is retained, the only thing different is the seat headcover. Seat pitch is pretty tight, especially at the last row. In-flight service was great and a complimentary drink was served. I still don't get why the airline doesn't offer domestic flights for the English version of the website. If you want to book on the airline's domestic flight, you can try booking via a travel agency in Korea or purchase the ticket at the ticketing office at Gimpo Airport.
Jin Air's Boeing 777-200ER HL7443 (CJU-GMP) Link to the trip report
Economy Class (2-5-2 section)
Thoughts: Jin Air has an interesting layout of both 2-5-2 and 3-4-3 Economy Class cabin (First 2 sections: 2-5-2 and last section: 3-4-3). This is the only airline with such configuration on a Boeing 777. The seats are from Korean Air's and I sat at the 3-seater (3-4-3). I chose the 3-4-3 to see for myself how cramp it was. Legroom space is not too bad but if you are flying alone, go for the 2-seater of the 2-5-2 configuration. As for the service, I have to give credit to the crew for handling this flight well. Not a frown on their faces at all even when they encounter some challenges from the passengers. Drink service was served and they basically completed it fast and within the time frame of the short 50 minutes flight. Well done to this set of the crew!
Overall rating: A+ Excellent service especially on the Boeing 777 flight. The aircraft may be transferred from Korean Air with its interior but comparing to other Low-Cost Carriers, the seat comfort is better. The airline also has a map of the aircraft type and will notify you of the windowless seats on the aircraft you are flying on. The on the ground and in-flight crew were excellent for both flights and this airline is definitely in my list of recommendation.
KLM's Boeing 777-200ER PH-BQD (KUL-CGK) (Link to the trip report)
Economy Class
My thoughts: 3-3-3 old Y class on this aircraft may be slightly more comfortable (less 1 seat a row) than the newly configured 3-4-3 Y class products introduced by KLM some time ago. However, I find this to be quite outdated and a bit cramped due to the seat pitch. I didn't quite enjoy this flight because my leg was aching towards the end of the 2 hours trip but at least the cabin crew were friendly. The snack bag was disappointing, I was hoping for a full meal for this 2 hours flight, I guess that's part of the reason for the cheap airfare.
Overall rating: B- Outdated In-flight product, average looking cabin and a light snack are not my taste. On the other hand, the in-flight service was good and that is probably one of the few highlights of this flight.
Economy Class
Korean Air's Boeing 777-200ER, HL-7750 (GMP-CJU) (Link to the trip report)
Economy Class
My thoughts: It was a great experience onboard this Korean Air's Boeing 777. Fitted with 3-3-3 seating configuration, it was equipped with not the most modern IFE system but it is comfortable with ample legroom space, I like it. In-flight service was excellent and I felt the crew dealt well with a full load of passengers on this short flight. The only drink was served.
Overall rating: A+ 3 great flights with Korean Air. The crew, in particular, were helpful and accommodating to my photography session especially after the flight. Not the most modern cabin around but at least for me, I can cope with it if I fly the 777 on long haul routes.
Malaysia Airlines' Boeing 737-800 9M-MSF (Photo) and 9M-MXE (SIN-KUL-SIN)
(Link to part 1 and Link to part 2)
Economy Class
My thoughts: I was delighted to have finally gotten the airline's newer Boeing 737-800s. Both flights were less than 30% full and most of us had the whole row to ourselves. How is the airline making money? Only the airline knows. For me, it was definitely a bargain as I enjoyed both the ride and the wonderful Malaysian hospitality.
Overall rating: B+ Personally I feel the cabin isn't as good as Malindo, mainly due to the tight seat pitch. This airline is now operating more of the 3 + hours routes with this aircraft and I will try to avoid if I am flying with this airline. In-flight service on both flights was good.
Mandarin Airlines ERJ-190 B-16826 (MZG-TSA) (Link to the trip report)
One Class: Economy
My thoughts: Another good experience with Mandarin Airlines with the crew being professional and friendly throughout. Unlike my previous experience, electronic devices in flight mode are allowed to be used and that makes my experience even more enjoyable. Excellent seat comfort, good aircraft and a good set of the crew - what more can I ask for? A choice of drinks was also offered on this flight.
Overall rating: A An enjoyable smooth flight from Magong to Taipei Songshan with splendid view, pity that the flight was too short for my liking. In conclusion, flying the ERJ-190 once again with this airline is an absolute delight!
Oman Air's Airbus A330-200 (Photo) and Airbus A330-300 A4O-DG and A4O-DB (SIN-KUL-SIN)
Economy Class
My thoughts: A jewel in the Middle East! This airline has fantastic in-flight products especially the business class cabin. I find the colours are attractive and seat to be comfortable especially in the 2-4-2 seating configuration. Although both flights were short, I got to enjoy the service from the lovely crew. For such a short flight to KL and back (Singapore), a drink and a snack (biscuit) were served.
Overall rating: A I heard positive feedback about this airline and I can see why. I love the interior of both J and Y class and service was good but not as polished as the top airlines. What I also appreciate is the snack provided for this short hop. Highly recommended!
Scoot's Boeing 787-8 9V-OFA (SIN-KHH) (Link to the trip report)
Economy Class
My thoughts: Getting a windowless seat was not part of the plan but it happened. Can't blame the airline but it would have been great if the seat map list which seats are windowless and offer a cheaper fare for it. In-flight service was average, maybe a couple of crew were better than the rest. Other than that it was a normal flight.
Overall rating: C+ The lack of window and tight legroom space made this flight experience a disappointing one. Unfortunately the flight was full so I couldn't change my seat but one of the crew was nice enough to offer me a window seat for the next sector (Kaohsiung to Osaka), unfortunately, I was going to Kaohsiung. That's nice of him though.
Thai Lion Air's Boeing 737-800 HS-LUH (DMK-SIN) (Link to the trip report)
One Class: Economy
My thoughts: Long queues at DMK airport and the web check-in was of no use since I had to join the line. No announcement of the delay and passengers were kept waiting without an update. Fortunately, the delay wasn't long. Cabin crew were friendly and it was nice to be flying on a new Boeing 737-800 with Boeing Sky Interior. Tight legroom space and I couldn't order the meal because the airline doesn't accept credit card - disappointing!
Overall rating: C Disappointed with the unpleasant check-in experience, no updates on the delay and only cash payment for the meal and duty-free items. On the bright side, the cabin crew's service was good and the airline provided a free snack and drink just before BOB began.
Tigerair's Airbus A320 9V-TAV (KUL-SIN) (Link to the trip report)
One Class: Economy
My thoughts: Despite the negative feedback I heard about this airline, everything went well. Not only was the check-in at KUL was efficient, but the in-flight service was also surprisingly good. I appreciate the presence of the enthusiastic crew and one even bow at the passengers after the flight! Seat pitch, on the other hand, was a disappointment, but that's a typical Low-Cost Carrier's configuration.
Overall rating: A- Points deducted for the uncomfortable seat pitch, and even my seatmate was also complaining. Fortunately, the flight took around an hour plus, so it was bearable. Apart from that, everything went well.
TigerAir Taiwan
Tigerair Taiwan Airbus A320 B-50007 (TPE-DMK) (Link to the trip report)
One Class: Economy
My thoughts: This aircraft is ex-Tigerair SG (9V-TAY) and the cabin seat is the same as Tigerair SG. I had to bear with the tight legroom space for the 3 hours plus flight. However the service was great, and the in-flight meal was decent. The cost of the meals is cheaper than Tiger SG and the menu selection is different.
Overall rating: B+ Overall, I find it to be a pleasant flight, the cabin crew were nice and professional, perhaps a bit reserved. In-flight meal was not bad and the cabin was clean. The flight was smooth making it a relaxing flight for all of us.
TransAsia's ATR-72-600 B-22822 and B-22815 (Photo) (TSA-HUN-TSA)
One Class: Economy
My thoughts: I was pleasantly surprised by the good in-flight service and comfort of the seats. The modern ATR-72-600 cabin by the manufacturer has done a great job in making the cabin more spacious and pleasing to look at while flying. There isn't any point during the flight that I feel unsafe, that's the most important thing.
Overall rating: A- On the whole, I enjoyed both flights even though my return flight was a bit nerve-wracking, not the airline's fault of course. After my experience, I won't hesitate to book myself with this airline again.
Uni Air's ATR-72-600 B-17001 (TSA-MZG) (Link to the trip report)
One Class: Economy
My thoughts: It was a pleasant ride from Songshan to Magong in very fine weather. The seat is comfortable with adequate legroom space and a good set of the crew with just a drink provided for this short hop. After seeing this plane type flying in and out of Songshan Airport many times, I am finally glad to have flown on one.
Overall rating: A- A pleasant flight with just a bit of bump during taking off. Cabin crew were friendly and legroom space is good enough for this short flight. In fact, the flight time went past too quickly for my liking.
Xiamen Air's Boeing 737-800 B-5386 (Old livery) SIN-XMN (Link to the trip report)
Economy Class (Old 737 Cabin)
My thoughts: Legroom space is not bad, but I remember my back got quite uncomfortable after 3 hours of flying. Unfortunately, the flight was full so I couldn't have the middle seat vacant. No individual IFE system, so I used my own Ipad for entertainment. In-flight meal was average, so was the service. Not the worst flight, but certainly not the most memorable. I was relieved when the aircraft touched down at Xiamen.
The airline's Boeing 737-800 B-5790 (New livery) (Link to the trip report)
Economy Class (Boeing Sky Interior)
My thoughts: The Boeing Sky Interior is certainly a difference between this and the old cabin, makes the passengers at least for me more comfortable. I could have the whole row to myself, not because of this passenger who decided to move from his original seat. At least I had the middle seat free. In-flight service and meal once again were average, but flying with Xiamen Air, you can be assured of safety as this airline won the best airline with the safety record in 2014.
This flight is my longest flight on a narrow-body so far, 5 hours and 15 minutes of flying including being placed on holding pattern while on approach to Changi Airport.
The airline's Boeing 787-8 Dreamliner B-2768 (Photo) and B-2762 (PEK-XMN-PEK) (Link to my part 2 and link to my part 3)
Economy Class
My thoughts: I was fortunate to have the whole row for myself and the middle seat vacant for both flights respectively. So the 3-3-3 seating configuration didn't affect me in any way. Even if it is full, I feel I would able to cope with it. Good legroom space with a comfortable seat. The IFE system is commonly used by other airlines so it is familiar to me - find the contents inside limited though. In-flight meal was very generous and decent while the in-flight service was surprisingly good.
Overall rating: B The Boeing 737 and 787 is huge indifference in terms of comfort and I would gladly choose the latter over the former any day when flying on domestic routes. For international flights especially flying in Asia, you don't get much of a choice. The Boeing 787 Dreamliner flies on a few domestic routes such as Fuzhou to Beijing and Xiamen to Beijing and once in a while, it flew to other cities, so if you get a chance, choose the 787 Dreamliner. Cabin service on the 787 is better and the in-flight meals on all my flights are decent, can't complain. Overall, this is one of the better airlines in China and for the ticket I paid, it is worth the value.
One Class: Economy
My thoughts: This airline certainly has something different from other Low-Cost Carriers and that is adding fun to the atmosphere. My first flight (TPE-CNX) in particular caught my attention with the catwalk and the appearance of V Bear. I was impressed with this set of the crew as they were working hard with smiles on their faces and seemed to be enjoying their jobs. One particular crew looked like one of the characters in a Japanese anime show! On the return flight, it was a slightly low key, but still, good service provided by the crew. Unfortunately, I couldn't get the warm food I wanted as they were sold out (both flights) and what amazed me about flying on this airline's A321 is the seat pitch, which is more comfortable than most LCCs. Only loses out to Air Busan's A321 which has better legroom space (34' inch).
My rating: A+ Good legroom space + Fun and loving crew + Good and inexpensive in-flight meal = Winner!
Charles Ryan's Award for year 2015!
This is based on my flights flown for this year and will be grouped under suitable categories.
*Do note that this award is based on my flying experience with the 23 airlines and has nothing to do with Skytrax or any others. My flights on Business and Premium Economy Class are limited so I may choose what I think is the best even if I haven't flown on those classes but have seen them for myself.
Best Premium Airline flew: Korean Air
For the experience. I particularly like the crew's uniform which matches the cabin interior, the in-flight service and the airline's livery.
Best Low Cost Carrier flown: V Air
Photo credited to worldairlinenews.com
It was a tough decision as there were another 2 airlines in mind, Jeju Air and Jin Air. Why did I pick this airline in the end? Well, it has a better website and better legroom seat pitch (Airbus A321) than the other 2 airlines.
Best Economy Class: EVA Air's B-16722 (77A configuration)
I find the seat to be comfortable.
Best In-flight Entertainment System: Air France
User-friendly IFE system packed with many contents!
Best Business Class: Oman Air
I didn't fly in this class with Oman Air, but among all the carriers I flown for this year, this is the clear winner. Configured in 1-2-1 on the airline's Airbus A330. Lots of space and aisle access to every passenger. I think this photo (above) tells you everything!
Best In-Flight Meal (Economy and Business): Asiana's Airbus A380 meal
The choice for the best in-flight meal is a tough one, as I haven't had a really good one, to be honest. I picked this because this actually tasted quite good.
Best In-Flight Service: Asiana Airlines (OZ722 Boeing 747-400 Combi)
This set of the crew is one of the best I come across, as the service was top notch! Having to deal with a full load of passengers, yet they were very courteous to each passenger and spent a bit of time explaining to the passengers with smiles. Walking around to make sure we are all comfortable and was incredibly patient with some passengers who just cannot follow instructions.
Fastest Flight: Xiamen Airlines Boeing 787-8 MF8102 (PEK-XMN) 34 minutes early
All thanks to B-2768!
Most enjoyable aircraft to fly on: FAT's MD-83 (B-28011)
Finally, after my 5th attempt, I got the airline's MD-83 and I got to fly on it twice!
The airline with the nicest livery: Jin Air
For me, I like the colour combination of the livery, looks stunning especially with the golden light shining on it.
Aircraft flew with the nicest Economy Class cabin: EVA Air (77A cabin)
Economy Class cabin
Most interesting Airport: Kaohsiung Airport
The walkway from the domestic to the international terminal has interesting aviation exhibits on display just like these plane models!
Best Airport Experience: Singapore's Changi Airport
Comfortable airport to hang out and also the fastest to come in and out the immigration.
Best Airport Lounge: Club Bauhinia (Hong Kong Airlines Lounge at HKG)
Basically, it has everything I need and also a window for me to enjoy the view! Food selection was good and the staff was there to update us on our flights.
Best Airport Staff: Seoul Gimpo Airport
The staff were very helpful and courteous and a couple of them went all the way to help me, in fact, they became my friends not long after.
For my Flight Review 2014 post, click here
Conclusion
Only Asian flights for 2015 but I managed to take my number of airlines flown so far to 81, climbing steadily to my target of 100 airlines. I hope in this new year, I would fly to another continent, possibly to Europe and Australia. The number of flights this year may be a few numbers short of breaking my record (most number of flights in a year), but I am satisfied with my choices of airlines and will be aiming to break the 90th barrier.
My upcoming trip in 2016
I will kick start my Flying Adventure in January to Thailand and Vietnam to catch 2 new airlines, 2 new cities and 1 new aircraft type. Trip reports will be done!
This trip will be broken up into 2 parts and will take place in the middle and the end of January.
Part 1:
SIN - Singapore
DMK - Bangkok Don Mueang
BKK - Bangkok Suvarnabhumi
SGN- Ho Chi Minh City
HAN - Hanoi
SIN-DMK (Scoot's B787-9)
BKK-SGN (Jetstar Pacific A320) - a new airline
SGN-HAN-SGN (Vietnam Airlines A350) - new aircraft type and city (HAN)
SGN-SIN (Vietjetair A320)
Part 2
SIN - Singapore
KBV - Krabi
BKK - Bangkok Suvarnabhumi
DMK - Bangkok Don Mueang
SIN-KBV (Thai Asia Airbus A320) New city and new airline
KBV-BKK (Bangkok Airways Airbus A319) New airline
DMK-SIN (Scoot Boeing 787-8)
Thanks for reading!
Hope you enjoy this review and do check out my upcoming 2016 trip reports!
For my 2016 review, click here
Cheers,
Charles
No comments:
Post a Comment